To become the all-time greatest Yankee "Brian," Brian McCann must out-do the man who signed him

Current All-Time Yankee Brians

1. Cashman
2. Doyle
3. McCann
4. Fisher
5. Boehringer
6. Butterfield
7. Bruney
8. Dayett
9. Dorsett
10. Little

(Honorary Mention: Due to "e" spelling and career achievements in bar-fights and crime: Taylor)